Penny had the best statistical season of any Dolphin QB since Dan Marino. That easily puts him at #1. Fiedler is no doubt #2, his heart and toughness deserves recognition, but he just wasn't that good. Everyone else either didn't fit or were just plain bad or worse.
Feidler is #2 simply because he was little more than a care taker Qb, he won games, was never a threat to lead us to a SB though.
The concept of this list is a complete joke to begin with. There were no "top" QB's for this franchise since. It's been a barren wasteland. Henne should be at the top simply because he's shown the only flashes of "top" talent this franchise has seen since Dan Marino.
I disagree. He should top the list simply based on having tools that none of our other QB's had at all. His tools aren't developed but I'd still take him over ANY of our past QB's hands down. Also the list should pretty much be only Pennington and Henne. The rest were completely forgettable.
outside of Penny, Fiedler and Henne ... the rest of the list is just plain terrible ... the only one i thought that could have done better with health and time was Griese ... in 3 years ... Henne will be the clear cut #1 - with a SB in tote ....
