Say what ? Pat Robertson says divorcing your spouse okay if they have Alzheimers
7 replies
Pat Robertson, TV star of the "700 Club" and evangelical Christian, says its okay to divorce your spouse if they are diagnosed with Alzheimer's.
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/17/us/pat-robertson-remarks-on-alzheimers-stir-passions.html
The Rev. Pat Robertson’s suggestion that a man whose wife was “gone” with Alzheimer’s should divorce her if he felt a need for new companionship has provoked a storm of condemnation from other Christian leaders but a more understanding response from advocates of families facing the shattering disease.
On his television show, “The 700 Club,” on Tuesday, Mr. Robertson, a prominent evangelical who once ran for president, took a call from a man who asked what he should say to a friend whose wife was deep intodementia and no longer recognized him.
“His wife as he knows her is gone,” the caller said, and the friend is “bitter at God for allowing his wife to be in that condition, and now he’s started seeing another woman.”
“This is a terribly hard thing,” Mr. Robertson said, clearly struggling with the subject matter. “I hate Alzheimer’s. It is one of the most awful things, because here’s the loved one — this is the woman or man that you have loved for 20, 30, 40 years, and suddenly that person is gone “
“I know it sounds cruel,” he continued, “but if he’s going to do something, he should divorce her and start all over again, but to make sure she has custodial care, somebody looking after her.”
When Mr. Robertson’s co-anchor on the show wondered if that was consistent with marriage vows, Mr. Robertson noted the pledge of “’til death do us part,” but added, “This is a kind of death.”
He said the question presented an ethical dilemma beyond his ability to answer. “I certainly wouldn’t put a guilt trip on you if you decided that you had to have companionship, you’re lonely, you have to have companionship,” Mr. Robertson said.
The reaction from many evangelical leaders, who see traditional marriage as the cornerstone of morality and society, was harsh and disbelieving.
“This is more than an embarrassment,” Russell D. Moore, dean of the School of Theology at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary in Louisville, Ky., wrote in a blog post on Thursday. “This is more than cruelty. This is a repudiation of the gospel of Jesus Christ.”
But Beth Kallmyer, senior director of constituent services at the Alzheimer’s Association in Chicago, declined to question Mr. Robertson’s remarks.
“This is a challenging, devastating and eventually fatal illness, and it affects everybody differently,” she said. “The most important thing is that families get help.”
In the association’s experience, she said, it is rare for people to get divorced because of Alzheimer’s. “Families tend to rally round and support the patient,” she said.
But Alzheimer’s, compared to many other fatal diseases, can go on for years, progressively worsening.
“The decisions people make are personal,” Ms. Kallmyer said. If a caller to the association’s helpline asked if it was reasonable to date someone else, she said, “we wouldn’t say one way or another — we’d walk them through their situation.”
Mr. Robertson helped make the Christian Coalition into a formidable political force in the 1990s and is a popular televangelist. But he has also stirred hostility from fellow Christians over the years with unorthodox statements, including a defense of China’s one-child population policy at one point and stating that dire events like the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks and the Haiti earthquake were punishments from God.
The home of The English Rugby Club - http://www.rfu.com/
Robertson is utterly wrong as he is so often! What ever happened to "in sickness and in health"? He has long been an embaressment to faithful Christians and this proves it again. I am appalled!
OHIOPHINPHAN
Witness to the first ever practice of the Miami Dolphins, 1966.
Eh, I think it is an interesting theological discussion OHp, if there is no taking and giving in marriage in the here after, but man and wife are one flesh (among other things found on I Cor 7), what is the proper principle?
And is a "civil" marriage the same as one sanctioned by a Congregation? Do note I chose the word Congregation carefully.
I am having issues with a new computer and a new call in ministry so I am slow getting back to the forums. Sorry for the delay in answering
My answer and the anger inherant in it arises mostly from the witness to the larger non-faith community. If we Christians refuse to live by the rules we set up for ourselves, then......
You ask a different question and a good one. Honestly, when I hear the phrase "a Biblical view of marriage" I chuckle. There was multiple marriage, levirate marriage, polygamy and all kinds of other "non-standard" practices throughout the Biblical witness. It seems that what most of the scriptural mandates regarding marriage are indeed talking about would be to call folks to acting faithfully in their witness to others. Husband of one wife for a bishop for example seems to leave open polygamy for others.
My comment centered on the vows that are a standard piece of most Christian weddings, a vow before God of fidelty and selflessness on behalf of the other. "Agape" love which Corinthians, Ephesians, and othe places call us to is all about sacrifice for the other party. In his advice Robertson allowed the caller's friend to put himself ahead of the other party and that to me is wrong headed and what I objected to so strenously.
OHIOPHINPHAN
Witness to the first ever practice of the Miami Dolphins, 1966.
Well OhioP, to me the Church Based Institution of marriage is getting mixed with the civil procedure of marriage, that is one of the reasons for the rhetorical questions, there are conditions that allow for a divorce, even in the New Testament, but the idea of a "marriage license" in my view would have been shunned in the early Church and among the Congregations that made up the Church.
I have something of a dim view of what "marriage" has come to mean, and I think Biblically speaking Robertson is not the guy I'd turn to for advice as I can see very little Christian Theology, or even philosophy in his approaches to issues and dispensing of advice. For example on his shows rarely is the Bible mentioned, and when it is, only in a one verse manner with little bother with attempting to expound upon what the single verse even means, on any level.
Why bother? That sort of sums up Roberston for me at least.
"BlameItOnTheHenne wrote:
What they don't know....
...and it's not like she'll miss whatever sex they didn't have.
Headcoach material wouldn’t want to work somewhere they’re not trusted with actual football decisions.