Race For #1 Pick- Top Contenders

67 replies

JAjake23subscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 06:00 PM

I think this is a three team race between us, Indy and jax. The tough part for us is we will lose the strength of schedule tiebreaker against either so we need to finish one clear. I agree with everyone that says 1-15 will win this thing, if not 0-16. And as much as finishing 1-15 with the first pick is probably best case scenario,I would choose 0-16 with luck than 1-15 without him. I don't think the Detroit fans care about being 0-16 four years ago if stafford nets them a super bowl, and by all accounts luck is a much better prospect than stafford. We really need the colts to beat tenn this week, I wish that game was in Indy.

I don't see the rams as viable contenders as bad as they looked yesterday. They have 7 "winnable games" left. Same goes for Arizona, they are bad but their schedule is too soft to not win at least one more.

It's us, Indy or jax. Give me even odds on that and I will bet the mortgage.

mrozmrozsubscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 06:04 PM

"Idahophin wrote:

Since the Rams have Sam Bradford, would they be interested in a QB?

I keep seeing this question and my reply is, what has Bradford done over the past two (-) seasons to make you think they wouldnt take Luck and trade Bradford?

RIP CHP Officer Kirk Griess ID#15810
EOW 8/10/18

mrozmrozsubscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 06:07 PM

"jake23 wrote:

I think this is a three team race between us, Indy and jax. The tough part for us is we will lose the strength of schedule tiebreaker against either so we need to finish one clear. I agree with everyone that says 1-15 will win this thing, if not 0-16. And as much as finishing 1-15 with the first pick is probably best case scenario,I would choose 0-16 with luck than 1-15 without him. I don't think the Detroit fans care about being 0-16 four years ago if stafford nets them a super bowl, and by all accounts luck is a much better prospect than stafford. We really need the colts to beat tenn this week, I wish that game was in Indy.

I don't see the rams as viable contenders as bad as they looked yesterday. They have 7 "winnable games" left. Same goes for Arizona, they are bad but their schedule is too soft to not win at least one more.

It's us, Indy or jax. Give me even odds on that and I will bet the mortgage.

The Colts and Jags play twice this year... they either split or knock the other team out of the race but it aint gonna be both of them. ;)

RIP CHP Officer Kirk Griess ID#15810
EOW 8/10/18

JAjake23subscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 06:18 PM

I agree it can't be both but it will be one or the other that is our main competition. We really need them to split or the colts to win both and jax sneak one more win against tenn or Cleveland

RoninFin4RoninFin4subscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 06:23 PM

"Idahophin wrote:

Since the Rams have Sam Bradford, would they be interested in a QB?

Who knows, but I guarantee they'll be interested in the multiple 1st round picks any team willing to move up for Luck would give them. Plus, the Rams have Bradford and his contract that was signed BEFORE the new CBA; they're on the hook for a lot of money tied up in Sam Bradford. If they get multiple picks as compensation for the right to take Luck, they could get a good number of players that will help them out.

@KevinMD4

PSGPSGforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 06:25 PM

"Aqua4Ever04 wrote:

That's the only game I see us having the potential to win. But then I think about Brian Orakpo and Ryan Kerrigan coming off the edge and it's good night. Also Matt Moore throwing into that secondary is a scary thought as well.

I think we'll be 0-11 by Thanksgiving and everybody else will have won at least one. From there, I think we'll upset somebody, just can't figure out who yet.

Yeah, I doubt we beat the Skins. Anyone thinking that game is winnable is seriously underestimating that D. Orakpo and Kerrigan will tear our oline apart. Moore throws at least 2 picks.
Final score: Washington 23, Miami 12

JajJajNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 06:26 PM

You better hope Colombo stays because if they fix that right side and try some new things like say Cook at RG and Garner at RT we're going to win football games.

Bring this man back into the fold if you want some real leadership on this team.

djphinfandjphinfansubscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 06:29 PM

"RoninFin4 wrote:

Who knows, but I guarantee they'll be interested in the multiple 1st round picks any team willing to move up for Luck would give them. Plus, the Rams have Bradford and his contract that was signed BEFORE the new CBA; they're on the hook for a lot of money tied up in Sam Bradford. If they get multiple picks as compensation for the right to take Luck, they could get a good number of players that will help them out.

hell yeah, if I'am them I stick with bradford, and draft Trent richardson or Lamichael James on that turf, then Blackmon, and walk away with a smile on my face.

Dolphins1BeatlesDolphins1Beatlesforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 06:34 PM

Colts might have a dilemma too. I mean, this team is BAD. Even with Manning they would not be super bowl material.

I wonder if they'd trade it and take Jones or Barkley or whoever, then use their extra picks to boost the rest of the team. They have a chance to win another Super Bowl with manning if they do that. And still have a possibly great QB, just not Luck.

1972 Miami Dolphins - The ONLY Perfect NFL Team

K I K O

JajJajNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 06:37 PM

They might trade Manning to the Jets or the Ravens and just draft Luck. Not that crazy of a possibility. Once Lewis and Reed retire those Ravens will go south quite a bit.

Bring this man back into the fold if you want some real leadership on this team.

gamblerxgamblerxNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 06:53 PM

Would be funny if 3 teams ended up 0-16.

texanphinatictexanphinaticforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 07:18 PM

"PSG wrote:

Yeah, I doubt we beat the Skins. Anyone thinking that game is winnable is seriously underestimating that D. Orakpo and Kerrigan will tear our oline apart. Moore throws at least 2 picks.
Final score: Washington 23, Miami 12

That offense is pretty terrible though, doubly so now that Grossman has reverted to form and Hightower is IRed and Moss is out for the next 5-7 games.

Bad teams like us, the colts, jags, etc will only stand a chance against two types of teams - low scoring or mistake prone. To win a game we will essentially need to catch several breaks because we will be the underdog. If we can catch Washington in a game where Rex or Beck cough it up a few times, or the Giants when Eli has one of his brain fart games we could pull something out.

texanphinatictexanphinaticforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 07:20 PM

"Jaj wrote:

They might trade Manning to the Jets or the Ravens and just draft Luck. Not that crazy of a possibility. Once Lewis and Reed retire those Ravens will go south quite a bit.

I would think the Colts would do everything possible to at least keep Peyton out of the AFC. Seahawks, Niners, Skins, Vikes.
Those would be some of my first calls.

GunnerGunnerNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 07:53 PM

This site updates the SOS in season every so often: http://www.rogerspoll.com/nfl_2011_sos_wk6.html

Last update was week 6 ... not sure how he tabulates the score ... but as of week 6, we had the 4th toughest schedule to date ... which doesn't bode well for our draft tie breaker as the team with the weaker SOS gets the higher pick

PhinGeneralPhinGeneralsubscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 08:30 PM

"mroz wrote:

I keep seeing this question and my reply is, what has Bradford done over the past two (-) seasons to make you think they wouldnt take Luck and trade Bradford?

Might depend on what kind of salary cap hit they'd have to take for trading him.

BigDogsHuntBigDogsHuntNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 09:24 PM

"Gunner wrote:

This site updates the SOS in season every so often: http://www.rogerspoll.com/nfl_2011_sos_wk6.html

Last update was week 6 ... not sure how he tabulates the score ... but as of week 6, we had the 4th toughest schedule to date ... which doesn't bode well for our draft tie breaker as the team with the weaker SOS gets the higher pick

His SoS scores has nothing to do with draft formula.....

Its simply #of Wins of Opponents divided by Total # of games played by opponents....its the tie breaker for round 1 of draft following # of Wins of teams.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/standings/_/type/playoffs/sort/projectedLosses/order/true

You can use ESPN playoff...just sort by wins in reverse order, and use the SoS column that is already calculated to figure out all teams tied with same # of wins. The lowest SoS% will get the better draft slot for 1st round.

Right now, thru week 7. Wins then SoS % order

1. MIA 0 wins .579
2. IND 0 wins .609
3. STL 0 wins .639
4. AZ 1 win .436
5. JAC 1 win .575
6. MIN 1 win .609

Remaining Schedule:
Miami (0-6)- @NYG, @KC, WAS, BUF, @DAL, OAK, PHI, @BUF, @NE, NYJ

Indy (0-7)- @TEN, ATL, JAC, CAR, @NE, @BAL, TEN, HOU, @JAC

St Louis (0-6)- NO, @AZ, CLE, SEA, AZ, @SF, @SEA, CIN, @PIT, SF

Arizona- (1-5)- @BAL, STL, @PHI, @SF, @STL, DAL, SF, CLE, @CIN, SEA

Jags- (1-5)- BAL(MNF), @HOU, @IND, @CLE, HOU, SD, TB, @ATL, @TEN, IND

Minny- (1-6)- CAR, @GB, OAK, @ATL, DEN, @DET, NO, @WAS, CHI

BDH -

"To me, there are three things we all should do every day of our lives. Number one is laugh. You should laugh every day. Number two is think. You should spend some time in thought. And Number three is, you should have your emotions moved to tears, could be happiness or joy.

"If you laugh, you think, and you cry, that's a full day. That's a heck of a day. You do that seven days a week, you're going to have something special."

Jimmy V. (Mar '93)

GARDENHEADGARDENHEADsubscriber
Oct 24, 2011, 09:27 PM

JAX defense is looking good tonight!

Tanking is like taking a Greyhound bus cross-country. Sure, it may eventually get you where you want to go, but it’s messy and unpleasant and uncomfortable, it stinks, the entire time you’ll be wishing you weren’t there, and not everybody along for the ride is going to make it to the end. - Quote stolen from Deadspin

JWjw3102forum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 09:36 PM

"Clark Kent wrote:

There's only 3 teams in Contention IMO. Seattle, St. LOUIS and Miami. Peyton is probably coming back. And till I hear that he's not, I don't think they legit Co.te.sets. Lucky for us Seattle and St. Louis play in the kindergarten of football.

You have heard it now. Manning will not be back this season. The Colts are not going to make the playoffs and with his neck injury still not fully healed, the Colts have no desire to expose Manning to further injury this season. The owner of the Colts has already stated that he would gladly draft Luck if the Colts have the first pick in the draft. For the owner to make this statement, it certainly appears that he already knows Manning will not be back this year and that the Colts will be one of the few teams who will be vying for the top pick in the 2012 draft, based on their won-loss record.

GunnerGunnerNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 09:43 PM

"BigDogsHunt wrote:

His SoS scores has nothing to do with draft formula.....

Its simply #of Wins of Opponents divided by Total # of games played by opponents....its the tie breaker for round 1 of draft following # of Wins of teams.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/standings/_/type/playoffs/sort/projectedLosses/order/true

You can use ESPN playoff...just sort by wins in reverse order, and use the SoS column that is already calculated to figure out all teams tied with same # of wins. The lowest SoS% will get the better draft slot for 1st round.

Right now, thru week 7. Wins then SoS % order

1. MIA 0 wins .579
2. IND 0 wins .609
3. STL 0 wins .639
4. AZ 1 win .436
5. JAC 1 win .575
6. MIN 1 win .609

Remaining Schedule:
Miami (0-6)- @NYG, @KC, WAS, BUF, @DAL, OAK, PHI, @BUF, @NE, NYJ

Indy (0-7)- @TEN, ATL, JAC, CAR, @NE, @BAL, TEN, HOU, @JAC

St Louis (0-6)- NO, @AZ, CLE, SEA, AZ, @SF, @SEA, CIN, @PIT, SF

Arizona- (1-5)- @BAL, STL, @PHI, @SF, @STL, DAL, SF, CLE, @CIN, SEA

Jags- (1-5)- BAL(MNF), @HOU, @IND, @CLE, HOU, SD, TB, @ATL, @TEN, IND

Minny- (1-6)- CAR, @GB, OAK, @ATL, DEN, @DET, NO, @WAS, CHI

Never said it had anything to do with draft formula ... rather just data ranking SOS for games already played only. It does not include games remaining on the schedule

BigDogsHuntBigDogsHuntNew Member
Oct 24, 2011, 09:44 PM

"Gunner wrote:

Never said it had anything to do with draft formula ... rather just data ranking SOS for games already played only. It does not include games remaining on the schedule

Gotcha, wasnt sure if you were looking for the actual/relevant draft info...but this SoS scores stuff, weird, as I dont know how they are being calculated...but SoS% is what the Draft uses..so thats what I wanted to provide to help thru week 7.

BDH -

"To me, there are three things we all should do every day of our lives. Number one is laugh. You should laugh every day. Number two is think. You should spend some time in thought. And Number three is, you should have your emotions moved to tears, could be happiness or joy.

"If you laugh, you think, and you cry, that's a full day. That's a heck of a day. You do that seven days a week, you're going to have something special."

Jimmy V. (Mar '93)

ANandres2882New Member
Oct 24, 2011, 09:53 PM

"djphinfan wrote:

he will be missing Santonio holmes and Tim Hightower..2 players that were playing well...winnable game or miami

Santana Moss . . .

Someone check my math. It's apparently not very good.

ANandres2882New Member
Oct 24, 2011, 09:54 PM

"GARDENHEAD wrote:

JAX defense is looking good tonight!

Flacco looking bad . . .

Someone check my math. It's apparently not very good.

PandarillaPandarillaforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 11:10 PM

"BigDogsHunt wrote:

His SoS scores has nothing to do with draft formula.....

Its simply #of Wins of Opponents divided by Total # of games played by opponents....its the tie breaker for round 1 of draft following # of Wins of teams.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/standings/_/type/playoffs/sort/projectedLosses/order/true

You can use ESPN playoff...just sort by wins in reverse order, and use the SoS column that is already calculated to figure out all teams tied with same # of wins. The lowest SoS% will get the better draft slot for 1st round.

Right now, thru week 7. Wins then SoS % order

1. MIA 0 wins .579
2. IND 0 wins .609
3. STL 0 wins .639
4. AZ 1 win .436
5. JAC 1 win .575
6. MIN 1 win .609

Remaining Schedule:
Miami (0-6)- @NYG, @KC, WAS, BUF, @DAL, OAK, PHI, @BUF, @NE, NYJ

Indy (0-7)- @TEN, ATL, JAC, CAR, @NE, @BAL, TEN, HOU, @JAC

St Louis (0-6)- NO, @AZ, CLE, SEA, AZ, @SF, @SEA, CIN, @PIT, SF

Arizona- (1-5)- @BAL, STL, @PHI, @SF, @STL, DAL, SF, CLE, @CIN, SEA

Jags- (1-5)- BAL(MNF), @HOU, @IND, @CLE, HOU, SD, TB, @ATL, @TEN, IND

Minny- (1-6)- CAR, @GB, OAK, @ATL, DEN, @DET, NO, @WAS, CHI

Yes, out in front...Great post.

Dolphins1BeatlesDolphins1Beatlesforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 11:18 PM

Simple...hope the AFC South & AFC North & NFC South teams win...unless the Colts magically start winning.

I think the Rams will pick up wins at some point. Seahawks, Cardinals still on schedule.

1972 Miami Dolphins - The ONLY Perfect NFL Team

K I K O

HugeFinFanHugeFinFanforum_veteran
Oct 24, 2011, 11:59 PM

Alright Jags!

Log in to reply.