Please fill out this list - for record keeping purposes

Keep Parker and Landry, move stills..

Keep Gase (I think he'll rebound).

Cutler I'm now convinced is a "no" for the long term though he may rebound this year.

Those are the only two predictions I'll make right now.

"dirtylandry wrote:

1. Gase, yes
2. Tannehill yes
3. Cutler no
4. Phins this year for playoffs no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes
6. Offensive line, no
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes

Gase and Landry are the toughest decisions, could have gone the other way but give Gase a chance because of how he turned it around last year.
Parker over Landry only cos I want to see a downfield passing attack.

1. Gase, yes
2. Tannehill no
3. Cutler HELL NO!!!!!
4. Phins this year for playoffs HELL NO!!!!!!
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018, besides Mayfield and possibly falk at WASU all the rest are so so, Darnald is a typical usc qb that will flop and so is Rosen at ucla so I say no unless we can get one of those 2.
6. Offensive line, yes needs to add like always
7. Keep Parker over Landry, no need both.

"dirtylandry wrote:

1. Gase, yes or no
2. Tannehill yes or no
3. Cutler yes or no
4. Phins this year for playoffs yes or no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes or no
6. Offensive line, yes or no
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes or no.

Thanks

1 - Gase - YES
2 - Tannehill - NO
3 - Cutler - NO
4 - Playoffs? - YES
5 - QB '18 Draft? - YES
6 - O-Line - NO
7 - Parker over Landry? - EASY YES

1. Gase, yes
2. Tannehill, yes
3. Cutler .... I can't answer this yet. Can I answer at the end of the season?
4. Phins this year for playoffs, Leaning slightly towards no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes (though likely in the second round or lower)
6. Offensive line, We need to to draft high round guards.
7. Keep Parker over Landry, No. I say keep both.

"dirtylandry wrote:

1. Gase, yes or no
2. Tannehill yes or no
3. Cutler yes or no
4. Phins this year for playoffs yes or no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes or no
6. Offensive line, yes or no
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes or no.

Thanks

1) Yes to Gase.
2) Yes to Tannehill (since he's under contract and we will DEFINITELY see him next season)
3) No to Cutler (one year contract protecting against RT injury)
4) Too soon to tell on playoffs, probably no
5) Yes we draft a QB
6) Yes we keep an offensive line
7) No, we keep Parker and Landry

8) Bonus answer- No, I don't understand this poll after three weeks & 9k miles of travel. If I recall, most said our season was over last year in week 5.

"KeyFin wrote:

1) Yes to Gase.
2) Yes to Tannehill (since he's under contract and we will DEFINITELY see him next season)
3) No to Cutler (one year contract protecting against RT injury)
4) Too soon to tell on playoffs, probably no
5) Yes we draft a QB
6) Yes we keep an offensive line
7) No, we keep Parker and Landry

8) Bonus answer- No, I don't understand this poll after three weeks a 9k miles of travel. If I recall, most said our season was over last year in week 5.

Key, I'll answer #8 for you... It appears the point here is to be able to point out who's right, and who's wrong down the road, as if that really matters at the end of the day. I mean, outside of that I don't see the point here.

"brandon27 wrote:

Key, I'll answer #8 for you... It appears the point here is to be able to point out who's right, and who's wrong down the road, as if that really matters at the end of the day. I mean, outside of that I don't see the point here.

you nailed it

1. Absolutely, yes.
2. Yes.
3. No.
4. Undecided, but leaning towards no.
5. This is a must, though not necessarily to replace Tannehill in the short-term.
6. Yes to Tunsil and James, no to everyone else.
7. I'd keep Parker and Landry, if possible. But between the two, Parker over Landry.

"dirtylandry wrote:

you nailed it

Then why would anyone waste their time filling this out? The majority of your questions are way too soon to call, especially Gase. What will you do with this down the road? Point fingers and say, "You were wrong about so and so and such and such!!! ...at that moment in time."

Pointless.

What Gase did with this team last year has earned him a long leash. We don't even know if this season is a failure yet. Even if it is a failure he absolutely deserves a 3rd year in my opinion.

1. Gase, yes or no
2. Tannehill yes or no
3. Cutler yes or no (jury is out)
4. Phins this year for playoffs yes or no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes or no
6. Offensive line, yes or no
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes or no.

i love threads

1. Gase: Yes, but having some second thoughts. Will know more as Season plays out.
2. Tannehill: Yes, but conditional on Gase staying as a 'Yes'.
3. Cutler: 'Definite Maybe' as he is a last minute replacement. Need to see immediate improvement against Titans.
4. Phins this year for playoffs: Looks closer to a 'No' with the losses to Jets and Saints.
5. Phins draft a qb: No, not a first rounder anyway. A third or fourth rounder to develop is a good idea every year.
6. Offensive line: It was a question mark even with no more injuries. Not near enough resources put into getting Guards.
7. Keep Parker over Landry: I want to keep Parker/Stills/Landry, so cutting Maxwell and going young at CB is the plan for 2018.

1. Gase no
2. Tannehill yes
3. Cutler no
4. Phins this year for playoffs no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 no
6. Offensive line, yes or no, TRADE DUMP AND START OVER
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes

1. Gase, yes
2. Tannehill yes
3. Cutler maybe, probably a no
4. Phins this year for playoffs no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes
6. Offensive line, hell no
7. Keep Parker over Landry, want both, but starting to become disenchanted with Parker, also, not backing up a Brinks truck for Landry. So, if he wants money like a top 5 receiver, SEE YA

1. Gase no
2. Tannehill yes
3. Cutler the best option this year
4. Phins this year for playoffs no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 it depends on who is available/it is certainly
6. Offensive line, it needs major work
7. Keep Parker over Landry, hell no!

1. Gase, yes or no
2. Tannehill yes or no
3. Cutler yes or no
4. Phins this year for playoffs yes or no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes or no (I hope) they probably wont :(
6. Offensive line, yes or no (not sure what you are asking, if you asking if the unit is good that's how i answered)
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes or no. Keep both get rid of Stills

1. Keep Gase, it's only year 2.
2/3. Blow up QB. Both are a no, but Cutler is what we have for now. See what you can get for Tannehill down the road, if anything.
4. No playoffs IMO. Tough start with the traveling (thanks for another London home game Ross) and hurricane and this team is probably not good enough to overcome with the rest of this schedule. I'll keep hoping though.
5. Will we draft a QB? Probably not. This franchise thinks Tannehill is a very good QB so we will not draft a QB for the next year or 2. Should we? Yes IMO. Maybe Gase will speak up and convince them in a year or 2, but I doubt it, unless he can resurrect this season for leverage.
6. No. Rebuild.
7. Keep Parker, his contract isn't up for another couple anyway. Keep Landry only if his asking price is reasonable for a slot receiver. Replace him if not. Replace Stills with another big physical receiver. Then TE and QB become less difficult to overhaul.

For clarification......are you asking what we want to happen or what we think will happen?

I mean i assume everyone WANTS us to make it to the playoffs...but some of the other answers make me question what is going on.

"Fin D wrote:

For clarification......are you asking what we want to happen or what we think will happen?

I mean i assume everyone WANTS us to make it to the playoffs...but some of the other answers make me question what is going on.

stop attacking me!!!

wut? :)

"Fin D wrote:

For clarification......are you asking what we want to happen or what we think will happen?

I mean i assume everyone WANTS us to make it to the playoffs...but some of the other answers make me question what is going on.

For clarification Fin... you should have made a new thread.

1. Gase, yes but starting to lean no, need a full season.
2. Tannehill no
3. Cutler no
4. Phins this year for playoffs no
5. Phins draft a qb in 2018 yes
6. Offensive line, ?? Yes, we should have an OL. And yes, we should attempt to get better. No, we should not spend a first rounder if a legit QB (Darnold, Rosen, Jackson, Allen) is available.
7. Keep Parker over Landry, yes - Landry is good but replaceable. The intangibles are meh for me. Yeah he's got spirit, but it's not needed or worth extra money. Also not in love with his recent off field issue. We will need Carroo to step up into his place and for Parker to take another step.

Tannehill no.

Gase is looking like a no... cant call plays.

playoffs???

Cutler played smart and just threw the ball away instead of making stupid mistakes. Running every play is killing the offense.