Miami Dolphins Talking Points: Trouble at the cornerback position

24 replies

dolfan7171dolfan7171New MemberOP
Aug 13, 2010, 01:21 PM

http://blogs.palmbeachpost.com/thedailydolphin/2010/08/13/miami-dolphins-talking-points-trouble-at-the-cornerback-position/

1. The Dolphins could be in deep, deep trouble at cornerback with Will Allen out:

The Dolphins secondary got torched last year for 17 plays longer than 40 yards, most in the NFL. But they entered this season with plenty of hope for the defensive backfield, especially at cornerback, where they have two young, talented and highly-drafted starters in Vontae Davis and Sean Smith, and a trusty veteran in Will Allen to push them for a starting job and also handle the nickel role.

Two weeks into camp, though, the cornerback position may have emerged as the team’s biggest weakness.

Allen, 32, is out until at least the regular season opener after undergoing arthroscopic surgery on his left knee on Thursday. This is the same knee he tore up in October, ending his season. Though the surgery was considered minor, the continued knee problems surely can’t be a good sign for a 10-year veteran. Overall, the Dolphins have just seven healthy cornerbacks in training camp, after losing Evan Oglesby to an ankle injury this week.

Now the top candidates for the third cornerback position are perennial underachiever Jason Allen, who has been beaten as often as he has made a good play this camp (and throughout his career), and rookie Nolan Carroll, a potential star in the making, but coming off a gruesome leg injury and someone who has played just one full season of cornerback in his life (2008 at Maryland).

Behind those two are former practice squad player Nate Ness (who actually has had a decent camp), and training camp fillers like Kevin Hobbs and Ross Weaver. And let’s not anoint Davis and Smith quite yet, either. They’re still young, and were very much responsible last year for the Dolphins getting torched 17 times.

In short, the Dolphins could be in deep, deep trouble if Allen doesn’t make a quick, full return from this procedure. Don’t be surprised to see the Dolphins begin the season with a third or fourth cornerback who isn’t currently on the roster.

Win, Lose, or Tie, I will be a Dolphins Fan Until I Die:up:

MikeHonchoMikeHonchosubscriber
Aug 13, 2010, 01:24 PM

Fingers crossed that it's not that serious.

Headcoach material wouldn’t want to work somewhere they’re not trusted with actual football decisions.

padre31padre31luxury_box
Aug 13, 2010, 01:46 PM

Well now, Jason Allen comes full circle, when Lil nicky drafted him he mentioned that he could play corner or safety..now we will see if he has anything to offer.

JA..man..he used to be one of my guys to watch for improvement, when he starred on special teams I thought that was his ceiling, now we will find out as #32 will have a target on his back the moment when he lines up on a Wr.

SHShamboubouNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 01:53 PM

Vonte, Smith, Allen, and Carroll can do a good job. You put Will Allen back into that mix and I think your going to be fine. I still think our biggest problems last year were the play of the safties and LB's covering TE's than the CB's.

Hopefully with the change in defense that Nolan brings, some pressure on the QB, we give the CB's and LB's a more of a chance this year. Only time will tell.

I'm not looking for the best players, I'm looking for the right ones.

-Herb Brooks-

dolfan22dolfan22subscriber
Aug 13, 2010, 01:57 PM

Very interessted to see if Nolan Carroll and Nate Ness can transfer the positives they have shown so far to the field in a game when the bullets are actually firing.

The veteran aspect is maybe overplayed, many young / rookie CB's have stepped in and contributed. We saw that right here last year , albeit with growing pains.

Miami won't be counting on them to start though , so they can grow as the season unfolds and , fingers crossed, Will Allen can actually contribute in a significant way in a not too distant future.

Jason Allen has managed to survive so far despite being a washout basically except for special teams , and may have his best days still ahead of him. He deserves an extended audition at CB , and will now get that

LOLoyal FinNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 02:08 PM

I'm very concerned about our secondary. Hopefully some of these kids start making plays back there.

TEtexasPHINSfanNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 02:20 PM

In fairness, the report (and others I've read) only state he's out for the preseason. I have no reason to doubt the accuracy of those reports, he should be back for the bulk of the regular season I would think.

*

rafaelrafaelforum_veteran
Aug 13, 2010, 02:27 PM

I'm not as concerned about W. Allen. Going back in to clean up loose debris is fairly common, so I don't see this as an indication that he won't recover. Obviously it's a set back b/c he misses practice time and can't exert as much vet influence, but it's not damning. IMO there's no reason to believe that he won't be back for 15 or 16 games of the regular season. And if he is I think we have one of the strongest CB units in the league (safety is a different story). Now you have to bring in bodies for camp and as a just in case, but I'm not any more concerned about our secondary than I was going into camp. And I actually feel better about 5th CB due to Carroll's surprising showing thus far. If W. Allen was to miss significant time, then I'd rate our CBs with J.A. at the nickel as about middle of the pack at worst (again, not including the safeties).

the 23rdthe 23rdNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 02:33 PM

the three whipping boys:
Jason Allen, Paul Solai & Channing Crowder
will be redeemed under the Nolan Defense

yes, the FreeSafety remains our Achilles heel
& the inexperienced DefensiveBack our weak link

- Competition is the Elixir of Success -

RickyBobbyRickyBobbyNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 02:54 PM

This is a non story. We have our two starterrs returning healty and very confident under the new nolan scheme. And will allen isnt hurt he just cleaned his knee out. there are 40 year olds who do that on a regular basis bc of golf, so Im not that worried about him. And by all reports J.Allen has been doing well in camp so if he is our 4th cb we r in great position. look at other #4 cbs in the league. I think we have one of the best. And rounding of our group is a rookie that has been outstanding and is expected to contrivute so relaz everyone, our CBs r just fine

DesidesDesidesforum_veteran
Aug 13, 2010, 02:54 PM

I see the local guys have finally found something to complain about. It was weird, almost two weeks into camp and none of them have really complained. So much for that streak.

Will Allen will be fine.

@desides01

"Not you." — Tywin Lannister

NaboCaneNaboCaneNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 02:58 PM

Now the top candidates for the third cornerback position are perennial underachiever Jason Allen, who has been beaten as often as he has made a good play this camp (and throughout his career)...

For those touting Jason Allen's renaissance.

FinSaneFinSaneforum_veteran
Aug 13, 2010, 03:02 PM

We also have Frank Walker. Yes he sucks but its a body you might need.

rafaelrafaelforum_veteran
Aug 13, 2010, 03:10 PM

"NaboCane wrote:

For those touting Jason Allen's renaissance.

I wouldn't call it a renaissance. It's just the understanding +90% of the CBs get beaten for the catch +50% of the time. I'd imagine it's even higher for anybody playing in the slot. The important part is that the CB be able to make the tackle immediately after the catch and if he doesn't that you have a S in position to limit the YAC. So if J.A. is forced into action in the nickel and makes as many plays as he gives up, he should be no worse than most every other CB in the league. The key will be the play of Clemons and his ability to be an eraser back there whenever any of our CBs or front seven players miss.

KillerphinsKillerphinsNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 03:12 PM

I knew we wouldn't be able to count on Will Allen's health.
That is the very reason I figured him in the nickel. He will be back more than likely but he won't start. I keep telling people this kind of stuff but ya'll have deaf ears. :wink2:

FinSaneFinSaneforum_veteran
Aug 13, 2010, 03:15 PM

I still think Will Allen is the best CB on the roster. But his health is just not going to let up. As a nickel we're fine. Smith and Davis will be ok, Nolan Carroll and Jason Allen are ok as backups. Besides, he shouldn't miss much more than the regular season which is fine since we don't need to see what he can do. I'd much rather he miss the preseason matter of fact.

The Aqua CrushThe Aqua CrushNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 03:27 PM

If VD and SS play up to their potential and correct the rookie mistakes from last year this is a minimal issue.

I fully expect them to be solid lock down starters back there, with or without Will Allen. But even if Allen is back it makes us that much stronger and more stable. Because no doubt it hurts not having him in the lineup, he's consistent as they come.

padre31padre31luxury_box
Aug 13, 2010, 03:31 PM

"NaboCane wrote:

For those touting Jason Allen's renaissance.

Classic JA..however he actually did make plays in the last couple of games, he negated two TD catches and generally looked "okay".

PhinsRockPhinsRockluxury_box
Aug 13, 2010, 04:06 PM

"RickyC wrote:

This is a non story. We have our two starterrs returning healty and very confident under the new nolan scheme. And will allen isnt hurt he just cleaned his knee out. there are 40 year olds who do that on a regular basis bc of golf, so Im not that worried about him. And by all reports J.Allen has been doing well in camp so if he is our 4th cb we r in great position. look at other #4 cbs in the league. I think we have one of the best. And rounding of our group is a rookie that has been outstanding and is expected to contrivute so relaz everyone, our CBs r just fine

This, without all the spelling errors :lol: How do you relaz? :tongue2:

2011 & 2006 World Champions, 2013 National League Champions; St. Louis Cardinals!

GMJohnsonGMJohnsonNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 04:22 PM

The Dolphins could be in deep, deep trouble at cornerback with Will Allen out:

Statements like this remind me of why Parcells & co have no love for the media. Not just trouble, "deep, deep trouble". GTFOH. Will Allen missed 9 games last year, and he was slated to be the nickel corner in 2010. Who writes an article saying that a team will be in "deep, deep trouble" if they lose their 32 year old nickel back who's coming off of an ACL tear? C'mon man.

We're in deep trouble if Dansby, Brown, Marshall, Long, Carey, Henne, Starks, etc go down. Will Allen? No.

the 23rdthe 23rdNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 04:48 PM

over all we have talent & depth throughout the defensive backfield
the problem, as I see it, is experience to go along w/the depth & talent
having said that
maybe they can compensate, to a degree, through coaching & a w/ ferocious front seven

- Competition is the Elixir of Success -

RickyBobbyRickyBobbyNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 05:17 PM

"PhinsRock wrote:

This, without all the spelling errors :lol: How do you relaz? :tongue2:

If you would have listened to Wildcat Radio with Chris Cullen(SICK) then you would know how I relaz. Check it out tonight at 10pm

http://www.blogtalkradio.com/themensroom

FanMarinoFanMarinoNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 05:20 PM

Im pretty confident our young Cornerback tandem will come good. Playing Cornerback isnt the easiest position especially when you are Rookies. Considering that and the way they both showed they did not look out of place fills me more with confidence than dread going into this season. Jason Allen has never shown he was worth the high pick but hes hung around and maybe, just maybe he may show up and become a solid if not an elite Defensive Back. Im hoping Carroll is a diamond in the rough. Its been a few drafts since we have had a low pick player come through and cemented a place in the defense. I for one dont think its such a glaring weakness that some ppl think. :up:

the 23rdthe 23rdNew Member
Aug 13, 2010, 05:25 PM

maybe...
Friend FanMarino
have to wait & see
this will be a process
& everyone will be included
until they find the fit
Jason too :yes:

- Competition is the Elixir of Success -

SamphinSamphinNew Member
Aug 14, 2010, 02:34 PM

"Killerphins wrote:

I knew we wouldn't be able to count on Will Allen's health.
That is the very reason I figured him in the nickel. He will be back more than likely but he won't start. I keep telling people this kind of stuff but ya'll have deaf ears. :wink2:

I think it has more to do with most people having you on ignore. :shifty:

Log in to reply.