If you could start from scratch, who would you keep?

Including your picks, Long, Davis, and Marshall

Sent from my Samsung Moment via Tapatalk

Vontae, Long, Marshall, Soliai (stepping his game up big time), Dansby and the ones you mentioned.

Pennington, marshall,long,brown,Bess,Camarillo(oh wait), scratch him, Hartline, Fasano, Carpenter, polite

D ...Dansby, Smith, Wake, Misi, and Davis

the rest are average at best

Oops, I somehow forgot about Bess.

here is my list...

QB-
RB-Hillard
WR-Marshall, Bess
TE-Fasano
OL-Long, Carey
DL-Odrick, Langford, Mcdaniel, Solai,
LB-Wake, Chrowder, Dansby, Misi, Edds
DB-Davis, Smith, Clemons
K-Carpenter
P-Fields

forgive me for answering backwards...
we need:
a pro-bowl quality center & pulling guard
a franchise-quality qb
& a young RB with speed

"Slowmotion wrote:

Yet Pennington is on the list.

If the others on the list and not on my list had half the heart and intelligence Pennington has we would be in the superbowl

Pennington gets the nod by default

Marino

1. Mike Nolan

2. Karlos Dansby

3. Koa Misi

4. Odrick

5. Edds

6. Langford

7. Soliai

8. Tony "The Predator" McDaniel

9. Cam Wake

10. Nolan Carroll

11. Chris Clemons

12. John Denney

13. Brandon Marshall

14. Brian Hartline

15. Davone Bess

16. Jake Long

17. John Jerry

18. Roberto Wallace

19. Marlon Moore

20. Ricky Williams

21. Dan Carpenter

22. Brandon Fields

"Slowmotion wrote:

I have never once in my lifetime seen heart win a Super Bowl.

as much as i hate to say it...2001 Patriots...

2007 New York Giants...
1999 Rams...

"Slowmotion wrote:

I have never once in my lifetime seen heart win a Super Bowl.

as much as i hate to say it...2001 Patriots...

2007 New York Giants...
1999 Rams...

assuming we could fill all the holes with an upgrade but I would keep.....

Nolan
odrick
soliai
wake
dansby
davis
smith
carroll
clemons
long
carey
jerry
marshall
bess
fasano maybe, pretty much every one else has become expendable, IMO.

Marshall, long, brown, bess, and polite for offense. Wake, Dansby, Davis, smith, starks, and most important for our defense mike Nolan.

That's because it is intangible. Heart or dedication as others would call it is there. A player either has got it or he doesn't. 4 shoulder surgeries and countless rehab hours behind the scenes speaks for itself.

Other such players who have/had it:

Dan Marino
Jerry Rice
Zack Thomas
Jim Kelley
Warren Moon
Wes Welker
Davon Bess
Michael Vick

"NaboCane wrote:

1. Mike Nolan

2. Karlos Dansby

3. Odrick

4. Edds

5. Langford

6. Soliai

7. Tony "The Predator" McDaniel

8. Cam Wake

9. Nolan Carroll

10. Chris Clemons

11. John Denney

12. Brandon Marshall

13. Brian Hartline

14. Davone Bess

15. Jake Long

16. John Jerry

17. Roberto Wallace

18. Marlon Moore

19. Ricky Williams

20. Dan Carpenter

21. Brandon Fields

Misi.. Davis..smith?

I would keep everyone on the Defense because the offense needs upgrades so bad the defense can wait a year. Maybe another LB but thats it with Crowder being the guy I'd let go.

Offense Ronnie and Henne need to go As well as two or three of the lineman. AND DAN HENNING.

"djphinfan wrote:

Misi.. Davis..smith?

Holy ****, I had Misi and then somehow erased him! Good catch.

But no, if I were starting from scratch I would want better, more consistent Corners than Vontae and Smith.

What has Vontae been besides inconsistent? Spectacularly good one game,conspicuously absent the next.

And Smith is neither the hitting machine you would expect from a guy his size, nor consistently good in coverage.

Truly GOOD Corners are two things: consistently good in coverage, and able to create turnovers. These guys are neither.

You could argue that they will develop, but I don't see it there.

"NaboCane wrote:

1. Mike Nolan

2. Karlos Dansby

3. Koa Misi

4. Odrick

5. Edds

6. Langford

7. Soliai

8. Tony "The Predator" McDaniel

9. Cam Wake

10. Nolan Carroll

11. Chris Clemons

12. John Denney

13. Brandon Marshall

14. Brian Hartline

15. Davone Bess

16. Jake Long

17. John Jerry

18. Roberto Wallace

19. Marlon Moore

20. Ricky Williams

21. Dan Carpenter

22. Brandon Fields

The fact that Long is so low on your list makes it a joke.

"NaboCane wrote:

Holy ****, I had Misi and then somehow erased him! Good catch.

But no, if I were starting from scratch I would want better, more consistent Corners than Vontae and Smith.

What has Vontae been besides inconsistent? Spectacularly good one game,conspicuously absent the next.

And Smith is neither the hitting machine you would expect from a guy his size, nor consistently good in coverage.

Truly GOOD Corners are two things: consistently good in coverage, and able to create turnovers. These guys are neither.

You could argue that they will develop, but I don't see it there.

No VD!!!...PROPOSTEROUS!!!You need to embrace your disease Nob's...lol

Long
Marshall
Bess
Polite
R.Williams
Chad Pennington (hes a coach, but give him the 3rd QB role)
Wake
Davis
Smith
Bell
Dansby
Misi
Langford
Crowder (you need a mouth sometimes)
Carpenter (top 5 K IMO)
Fields (top 5 punter and hopefully special teams player of the week after his Jets performance)
Mike Nolan
Owner: Ross

"#1dolphinsfan wrote:

Marshall, long, brown, bess, and polite for offense. Wake, Dansby, Davis, smith, starks, and most important for our defense mike Nolan.

Can you fix your Signature and Photo please. I'm actually quite tired of seeing the wrong jersey number and photoshop job on a guy who has been with this team 14 games into the season. Besides, 15 isn't even Marshall.

I'm sure theres a wire photo somewhere you can use, and a mugshot on Dolphins.com.

Davis, Smith, Long, Henne, Pennington, Igognito, Carey, Marshall, Hartline, Carroll, Starks, Moses, Odrick, Langford, Bell, Henne.........Just to start.

ETA; Wake

Absolute Keepers (not necessarily all sure starters, might want to upgrade, but only players I can definitively say I want on the team next year, no matter what):

ST's: Fields & Carpenter & Denney.

D: Cam Wake; Davis; Dansby; Soliai; Odrick; Misi; McDaniel; Langford; Carroll; Edds;

(Can't say "absolutely" on Smith - he's inconsistent at times; I don't think he has the dedication and serious maturity that Vontae does; and he can't catch; just sayin' not "absolute").

O: Jake Long; Jerry; Marshall; Bess; Wallace.

Coaches: Mike Nolan; Darren Rizzi; Bill Sheridan.

Above all, with respect to keepers: the entire offensive staff must be gone - plus, gut the entire offensive office, replace the drywall ... everything; burn their furniture, carpeting, everything goes to the fire.

"Frumundah Finnatic wrote:

The fact that Long is so low on your list makes it a joke.

I don't think it was in any particular order.