Examine the Coachspeak- Dallas Thomas can be a "capable" Offensive Lineman
46 replies
Per Joe Philbin, via Adam Beasley on twitter about an hour ago.
To me, "capable" sounds like a weak term for someone drafted in the 3rd round. Sounds as if Joe didn't want to commit to saying he can be a good lineman, yet at the same time isn't going to come right out and say the guy sucks Donkey ba**s.
I'd like to listen to the presser to hear how it came out of his mouth, but it still doesn't seem like much of an endorsement of where Thomas is.
Given the complexity of the schemes and assignments for every position, they don't play rookies until they have learned a large enough portion of the playbook to the coaches satisfaction. You'd think they'd simply things ala Chip Kelly, to get the talent on the field.
That said, either these coaches have things too complicated or are too stringent in expectations, they rookies are intellectually struggling to learn assignments, or they just weren't good picks to begin with. I find that hard to believe with Jordan, Taylor, and Davis. I have zero faith in Turner's abilities at this point. Especially with Dallas Thomas and former first round pick Danny Watkins not playing any snaps in a game as bad as this last loss.
It's irritating to see rookies playing and flourishing on other teams and our guys either are limited in snaps or don't play at all. Given the performances of some of the 2nd and 3rd string vets, I'd rather take my lumps with the rookies this season and get them much needed game experience.
"cuchulainn wrote:
Given the complexity of the schemes and assignments for every position, they don't play rookies until they have learned a large enough portion of the playbook to the coaches satisfaction. You'd think they'd simply things ala Chip Kelly, to get the talent on the field.
That said, either these coaches have things too complicated or are too stringent in expectations, they rookies are intellectually struggling to learn assignments, or they just weren't good picks to begin with. I find that hard to believe with Jordan, Taylor, and Davis. I have zero faith in Turner's abilities at this point. Especially with Dallas Thomas and former first round pick Danny Watkins not playing any snaps in a game as bad as this last loss.
It's irritating to see rookies playing and flourishing on other teams and our guys either are limited in snaps or don't play at all. Given the performances of some of the 2nd and 3rd string vets, I'd rather take my lumps with the rookies this season and get them much needed game experience.
Agree. And this is part of why I am not fully against replacing the coaching staff DURING this season. Especially if we look terrible, flat and disinterested as a team this Sunday.
Also, a great coach would change the scheme or gameplan to accomodate for the pieces he DOES have and put them in a position to succeed at what they CAN do well.
Honestly, I think we are victim of a mediocre GM getting us players that are not always great fits or need development...
PLUS
A mediocre coaching staff that's no good at coaching them up, or designing their coaching plan to adapt and get the most out of who they have.
Either one alone, mediocre GM or mediocre Coaching staff, would be fine if the other arm was great... but together you get problems.
"Bpk wrote:
Also, a great coach would change the scheme or gameplan to accomodate for the pieces he DOES have and put them in a position to succeed at what they CAN do well.
Honestly, I think we are victim of a mediocre GM getting us players that are not always great fits or need development...
PLUS
A mediocre coaching staff that's no good at coaching them up, or designing their coaching plan to adapt and get the most out of who they have.
Either one alone, mediocre GM or mediocre Coaching staff, would be fine if the other arm was great... but together you get problems.
Yes, and that's what made Don Shula such a great coach. He adapted to the strengths of his players to get them on the field and performing.
Philbin's coaches are more concerned with the players adapting to the schemes and *****ing about how well they execute.
I'll fess up. I was a fan of Dallas Thomas leading up to the draft and was pretty happy when they took him. I thought he was the LG of the future. I wonder if the root of his problems are basic core strength (a concern of his coming from Tennessee that I'm guessing is magnified by the shoulder injury) and the fact that Jim Turner had him taking snaps at every position except center in training camp. This kid was a solid, solid LG at Tennessee; he's not a tackle, left or right, and I don't think at the end of the day he'll ever be that classic road-grading type of RG. He's mobile and can pull well, yet Miami seemed resistant to using him there due to Richie Incognito's presence.
I think, at the very least, he's in competition for the LG spot in 2014 training camp.
@KevinMD4
I think we all know Dallas is very capable of one thing… that is not being active on Sundays...
RIP CHP Officer Kirk Griess ID#15810
EOW 8/10/18
"RoninFin4 wrote:
I'll fess up. I was a fan of Dallas Thomas leading up to the draft and was pretty happy when they took him. I thought he was the LG of the future. I wonder if the root of his problems are basic core strength (a concern of his coming from Tennessee that I'm guessing is magnified by the shoulder injury) and the fact that Jim Turner had him taking snaps at every position except center in training camp. This kid was a solid, solid LG at Tennessee; he's not a tackle, left or right, and I don't think at the end of the day he'll ever be that classic road-grading type of RG. He's mobile and can pull well, yet Miami seemed resistant to using him there due to Richie Incognito's presence.
I think, at the very least, he's in competition for the LG spot in 2014 training camp.
I'd agree with that, and also agree all the pre-season shuffling the coaching staff put him through probably did little to help get his career off on a good start. I think the second half of the season, even if he doesn't play, will be important for him to show that he can be relied upon to compete for the starting guard position.
When a drafted 3rd round Guard can't crack a unit that has been a car wreck it says volumes. Un-freekin-believable.

"RoninFin4 wrote:
I'll fess up. I was a fan of Dallas Thomas leading up to the draft and was pretty happy when they took him. I thought he was the LG of the future. I wonder if the root of his problems are basic core strength (a concern of his coming from Tennessee that I'm guessing is magnified by the shoulder injury) and the fact that Jim Turner had him taking snaps at every position except center in training camp. This kid was a solid, solid LG at Tennessee; he's not a tackle, left or right, and I don't think at the end of the day he'll ever be that classic road-grading type of RG. He's mobile and can pull well, yet Miami seemed resistant to using him there due to Richie Incognito's presence.
I think, at the very least, he's in competition for the LG spot in 2014 training camp.
I thought he projected to be a solid pro....
Think about this, we have gotten nothing out of the returner position this year, garbage play...we have a player on our roster who happens to have the best hands on the team, who is physical and strong with pretty good speed, he was also a very good returner in college..his name is Rishard Matthews, you know that guy that we've been clamoring for way before last week to get serious playing time?...If Rishard Matthews told the coaches he doesn't want to return punts or kicks, I can understand, but I don't think that's the case...two misevaluations..one on Thigpen, the other on not recognizing Matthews..kick that dude the ball, he will catch it securely, and he will do somethin with it..

"djphinfan wrote:
I thought he projected to be a solid pro....
Think about this, we have gotten nothing out of the returner position this year, garbage play...we have a player on our roster who happens to have the best hands on the team, who is physical and strong with pretty good speed, he was also a very good returner in college..his name is Rishard Matthews, you know that guy that we've been clamoring for way before last week to get serious playing time?...If Rishard Matthews told the coaches he doesn't want to return punts or kicks, I can understand, but I don't think that's the case...two misevaluations..one on Thigpen, the other on not recognizing Matthews..kick that dude the ball, he will catch it securely, and he will do somethin with it..
Did you see Sherman's quote about Matthews from Tuesday this week, about his being surprised because Matthews has a "sleepy-eyed look" and didn't look like he was paying attention. I mean, if that's really their reasoning for not giving Matthews more playing time...well, I think that just speaks to how out of touch this coaching staff really may be, especially in the wake of the Incognito-Martin ordeal.
I do recall Matthews being a very good returner at Nevada. Hard to replace Thigpen for me though. He was the only guy in the NFL last year that was top 5 in returning both kicks and punts; I think he's top 6 in both again this year. That said, I think if you can find more value in Thigpen's roster spot by giving it to someone at another position (like a DT better than Isaako Aatui), I'd by all means love to give Matthews a shot.
Matthews, I think, is going to be a solid player for quite some time in the near future.
@KevinMD4
"FanMarino wrote:
When a drafted 3rd round Guard can't crack a unit that has been a car wreck it says volumes. Un-freekin-believable.
The question is, is that really due to Dallas Thomas, or is that due to the coaching staff and veterans already in place?
@KevinMD4
"cuchulainn wrote:
Given the complexity of the schemes and assignments for every position, they don't play rookies until they have learned a large enough portion of the playbook to the coaches satisfaction. You'd think they'd simply things ala Chip Kelly, to get the talent on the field.
That said, either these coaches have things too complicated or are too stringent in expectations, they rookies are intellectually struggling to learn assignments, or they just weren't good picks to begin with. I find that hard to believe with Jordan, Taylor, and Davis. I have zero faith in Turner's abilities at this point. Especially with Dallas Thomas and former first round pick Danny Watkins not playing any snaps in a game as bad as this last loss.
It's irritating to see rookies playing and flourishing on other teams and our guys either are limited in snaps or don't play at all. Given the performances of some of the 2nd and 3rd string vets, I'd rather take my lumps with the rookies this season and get them much needed game experience.
That seems to be the case this year, but last year our rookies played a lot more. Tanny and Martin full time, and Vernon, Shelby, and Miller fairly significant amounts of snaps. Our top 3 rookie draft picks this year were all coming off injuries/surgeries that set them back for varying degrees throughout camp. Then rookie #4, Davis, got hurt later in camp and was set back too. That was one thing that struck me watching the '13 draft unfold. Why was Ireland investing so highly in damaged goods rather than guys more ready to contribute? I guess he was looking more long term?
“... I hope I never ridicule what is wise or good. Follies and nonsense, whims and inconsistencies do divert me, I own, and I laugh at them whenever I can.”
― Jane Austen, Pride and Prejudice
"RoninFin4 wrote:
Did you see Sherman's quote about Matthews from Tuesday this week, about his being surprised because Matthews has a "sleepy-eyed look" and didn't look like he was paying attention. I mean, if that's really their reasoning for not giving Matthews more playing time...well, I think that just speaks to how out of touch this coaching staff really may be, especially in the wake of the Incognito-Martin ordeal.
I do recall Matthews being a very good returner at Nevada. Hard to replace Thigpen for me though. He was the only guy in the NFL last year that was top 5 in returning both kicks and punts; I think he's top 6 in both again this year. That said, I think if you can find more value in Thigpen's roster spot by giving it to someone at another position (like a DT better than Isaako Aatui), I'd by all means love to give Matthews a shot.
Matthews, I think, is going to be a solid player for quite some time in the near future.
I think we overestimate the mental and emotional intelligence of NFL coaches because we admire the sport so much.
"cuchulainn wrote:
Given the complexity of the schemes and assignments for every position, they don't play rookies until they have learned a large enough portion of the playbook to the coaches satisfaction. You'd think they'd simply things ala Chip Kelly, to get the talent on the field.
That said, either these coaches have things too complicated or are too stringent in expectations, they rookies are intellectually struggling to learn assignments, or they just weren't good picks to begin with. I find that hard to believe with Jordan, Taylor, and Davis. I have zero faith in Turner's abilities at this point. Especially with Dallas Thomas and former first round pick Danny Watkins not playing any snaps in a game as bad as this last loss.
It's irritating to see rookies playing and flourishing on other teams and our guys either are limited in snaps or don't play at all. Given the performances of some of the 2nd and 3rd string vets, I'd rather take my lumps with the rookies this season and get them much needed game experience.
Maybe that's a reason for the excessively sloppy play- that perhaps a complicated system is making the players spend too much thinking rather than playing. I mean, we're seeing a greater degree of player mental errors out there than we should, which seems out of a place when coached by a guy who's such a stickler on X's & O's and execution. Perhaps he's too much of a stickler and it's leading to mental errors and sloppiness.
"RoninFin4 wrote:
Did you see Sherman's quote about Matthews from Tuesday this week, about his being surprised because Matthews has a "sleepy-eyed look" and didn't look like he was paying attention. I mean, if that's really their reasoning for not giving Matthews more playing time...well, I think that just speaks to how out of touch this coaching staff really may be, especially in the wake of the Incognito-Martin ordeal.
I do recall Matthews being a very good returner at Nevada. Hard to replace Thigpen for me though. He was the only guy in the NFL last year that was top 5 in returning both kicks and punts; I think he's top 6 in both again this year. That said, I think if you can find more value in Thigpen's roster spot by giving it to someone at another position (like a DT better than Isaako Aatui), I'd by all means love to give Matthews a shot.
Matthews, I think, is going to be a solid player for quite some time in the near future.
Thigpen is nowhere near the top five in KR's or PR's this year.http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?tabSeq=0&season=2013&seasonType=REG&d-447263-n=1&d-447263-o=2&d-447263-p=1&statisticCategory=KICK_RETURNS&d-447263-s=KICK_RETURNS
"FanMarino wrote:
When a drafted 3rd round Guard can't crack a unit that has been a car wreck it says volumes. Un-freekin-believable.
That falls on the Staff, not the player, I'd love for someone to say with a straight face that Thomas cannot possibly be an upgrade on the worst Right Tackle in the NFL.
Much in the way that a traffic cone is "capable"
Headcoach material wouldn’t want to work somewhere they’re not trusted with actual football decisions.
"RoninFin4 wrote:
The question is, is that really due to Dallas Thomas, or is that due to the coaching staff and veterans already in place?
Will we find out? That's where the problem lies right now. For all we know we might cut Thomas after this season and find him starting on a decent, playoff bound team. Im getting annoyed with our so called experts drafting players at a decent spot in the draft and not seeing them given a chance to show especially on that O-Line which is the biggest weakness on the team bar none. How can you draft a player high and not get a sniff when that unit is a total shambles? It beggers belief. I won't even go there with Jordan....great upside apparently but has weaknesses according to the limited ability wise coaches that cant utilize him. 9 snaps in the last game? Says everything you need to know about the coaching staff.

"RoninFin4 wrote:
Did you see Sherman's quote about Matthews from Tuesday this week, about his being surprised because Matthews has a "sleepy-eyed look" and didn't look like he was paying attention. I mean, if that's really their reasoning for not giving Matthews more playing time...well, I think that just speaks to how out of touch this coaching staff really may be, especially in the wake of the Incognito-Martin ordeal.
I do recall Matthews being a very good returner at Nevada. Hard to replace Thigpen for me though. He was the only guy in the NFL last year that was top 5 in returning both kicks and punts; I think he's top 6 in both again this year. That said, I think if you can find more value in Thigpen's roster spot by giving it to someone at another position (like a DT better than Isaako Aatui), I'd by all means love to give Matthews a shot.
Matthews, I think, is going to be a solid player for quite some time in the near future.
11th in kickof return...18 th in punt return..
Edit...better than I thought, but I'm still mad about not signing Trindon Holliday after he was available, right after we played him in a preseason game two years ago..I mean you see the guy live, he tears your ass up, he's available, and you snooze..
That's frustrating.

It means he is not capable now. That's all that needs to be said.
banned
"padre31 wrote:
That falls on the Staff, not the player, I'd love for someone to say with a straight face that Thomas cannot possibly be an upgrade on the worst Right Tackle in the NFL.
Totally agree. If the hype gets put on the player by his drafting position then yes? If that's the case then Ireland should be gone...yesterday. If i hear Dallas Thomas is suddenly opening lanes for his teams running back in 2yrs time then its also on Philbin. I expect the Dolphins coaches to notice talent or is that expecting too much? If our O-Line is so bad then why can't we slide in an ex Eagles Guard with NFL experience or a 3rd rounder with upside? It's becoming blatantly obvious the coaching staff has no confidence in Dallas Thomas to crack a unit that is on a roll to crack the most sacks given up by an NFL O-Line.

More damning stuff from Barry Jackson. Joe Philbin believes Dallas Thomas will be a capable tackle, not just a lineman, but a tackle. This is wrong. He also says he likes Kevin Coyle's scheme and wouldn't switch back to a 3-4.
Coach Philbin is worse than I thought.
As far as Thigpen's return stats, what were they before the Tampa game? I could have sworn ESPN posted a graphic that had him in the top 6 in both.
@KevinMD4
"djphinfan wrote:
11th in kickof return...18 th in punt return..
Edit...better than I thought, but I'm still mad about not signing Trindon Holliday after he was available, right after we played him in a preseason game two years ago..I mean you see the guy live, he tears your ass up, he's available, and you snooze..
That's frustrating.
As a whole, ST play has declined this year Deej, pretty much across the board in fact.