Pierre Garcon?

The last thing this team needs is another #2 WR.

 

I don't trust a quarterback that's played for Peyton Manning as a #2 WR. Chances are he won't nearly be as good outside as a #1.

 

Garcon is Bess

He has Wayne, we don't.

We need a true # 1 guy, not Garcon.

 

No, he is not. He had a great game today, he has a very good number 1 to take the pressure off him.

And if Gonzales didn't get hurt you would never have heard of him.

The guy is a good number 2 or 3 wr. He is not a number 1.

 

A miracle.

 

why would the Colts ever want to trade him?

 

to those of you that are saying the Garcon = Bess... I would have to disagree, Garcon is a much more physcial player then Bess is.

I don't know that Garcon is ever going to be a #1 but IMO the guy is going to be a very good WR in the NFL. The guy has great hands... and I mean great.

 

Without Reggie Wayne this thread doesn't get started because Garcon is blanketed by Revis today.

 

Garcon is made better made Manning but he is most definitely better than Bess. He is bigger, faster and has really good hands.

 

put Ginn in a colts uniform and the man would avg. 100 yards a game no sweat.

There offense is a well oiled machine that speed wrs excel in. In fact, if Ginn isn't a dolphin next year, i am positive he will be a colt or an eagle.

 

I'm not so sure about that. I'm not saying Garcon is mega-talented like Wayne but I think the game plan, or second half adjustments if you want to call it, could have played a big part in Garcon's effectiveness even if Revis was covering him. They threw a lot of underneath stuff on three step drops so Garcon probably could have had quite a few catches, a few YAC yards too IMO.

 

I think this whole thread isn't very well thought out. What team trades a player after their second season? Especially when it's a successful sophomore season. It would make absolutely no sense.

 

I have no interest in Brandon Marshall. The guy is one step away from a long suspension. No thanks.

 

Garcon is the heir apparent to Wayne.......he won't be going anywhere.

He's not in any way similar to Bess and on this team he'd easily be the number one WR.

 

I was thinking the same thing.Hell why don't we go after percy harvin while were at it.After that we will go after jarious byrd to fix our safety problems.

 

Guys looked really good in the games I've seen him play. Granted he has one of the greatest ever throwing to him but I do think he's at the very least a legit #2. I don't see us even trying to get a deal done for him but if we could get him I'd love to have him. He would upgrade our WR corps.

 

He just looks really good because Peyton makes all his wideouts look good. I don't know if he would have the same results playing here or anywhere else. But give him props he has taken advantage of that opportunity with Gonzales getting injured.

But Henne does need a big targer wideout. It would help a lot of things on our offense. Don't think Garcon is the answer however.

 

Maybe he's not #1 material, but he's a sight better than Bess once he gets the ball in his hands. He doesn't go down nearly as easily as Bess does. He's not the answer for our question (a #1 WR), but I'd take him over Bess as a our #2 or #3 any day of the week...and Bess isn't a slouch...

EDIT: Putting it another way, the difference is that once he catches the ball, Garcon is like a RB where Bess is still a WR when he catches the ball....just not enough power in Bess...

 

Just to be clear this is Garcon's 2nd year, your point still stands though even for a 2nd year guy.

 

I'm sorry but I think Camarillo is better than Bess!

 

I cant wait until after the Superbowl

*insert player's name here* Kicked *** why dont we sign/trade for him?

 

Peyton makes all his receivers look better than they are

 

I think the better way to look at is instead of wanting to trade for a guy like Garcon (or Collie for that matter), we should be looking to draft players of their ilk. And, to prove how you can find talent like theirs throughout a draft, Garcon was a 6th round pick, and Collie was a 4th round pick.

That's one reason the Colts are good season after season is because Polian knows how to find talent. Both those guys came up big yesterday, all season really. They lost Gonzalez for the season, and their passing attack didn't skip a beat. A lot of that is Peyton, I know. He makes average WR's look very good. But, he can't run the routes and make the catches too. You gotta tip your cap to both those kids...they made a lot of big plays in a very big game yesterday.

 

Indy wouldn't trade him at this point in his career. No reason. Teams don't trade 23-year-old talents on the rise.

 

I like him but he doesn't possess that playmaking ability, he isn't the fastest guy on the field, although a very tough guy, I don't see him being that playmaking stud.....and oh yeah, he has Peyton Manning throwing to him, who could even make Ted Ginn look good.....

 

well your wrong.... he is not....

 

Pierre Garcon is a nice player, and definitely better than Davone Bess. Hate to say it, but not only is he A LOT faster, he's bigger and more physical.

Besides, I think we'd have a better shot at Austin Collie. White WR's FTW!

 

I agree, i think garcon could be a legit #1 and id like to see him in miami.

 

We already have him.

 

Clearly we already have him when Bess is a guy that rarely ever pushes the issue up the field with his 4.6 speed while Garcon can flat out burn.

 

Not seeing the similarities to Bess at all. One guy is 5"10, 190, runs a 4.6 and is suited to the slot.
The other is 6"0, 210, probably runs in the 4.4 range and plays outside.
No idea why Garcon is being compared to Bess tbh.

 

I'm not a big fan of trying to get our superstars by trading with other teams. You get raped in draft picks that way. The best way is to draft your own players. And sometimes you hit on a nugget in free agency but that has it's own risks with cap space ala Gibril Wilson.

if we need a WR that bad we can draft one. Someone will talent will be available for us in the 2nd round whether it's Golden Tate or Arrelious Benn but we can get a good WR this year if we want.