http://www.footballoutsiders.com/ramblings/2009/2009-nfl-draft-report-card-report Here's an article that analyzes the post-draft grades of: * Jason Cole (AFC) and Charles Robinson (NFC), Yahoo.com * John Czarnecki, FoxSports.com * Mel Kiper, ESPN.com * Tom Mantzouranis, NFL.Fanhouse.com * Pete Prisco, CBSSports.com * Rob Rang, NFLDraftScout.com * Gregg Rosenthal and Evan Silva, Rotoworld.com/NBCSports.com * Ross Tucker, SI.com * Larry Weisman, USAToday.com Miami's GPA is a 2.53
Even though I find it silly to grade a draft days after it was made and before any picks even make the club, this was interesting to see the reviews of so many draft "experts" in one place.
Everyone knows how silly draft grades are. Even the graders all begin their grades with the caveot that draft grades are stupid...but they do them anyway...and we read them anyway!!! Kinda like ESPN!
I'm waiting to see the ratings from 3 years ago and see how they compare to what each team actually did.
Tied with KC for 3rd worst draft by Kiper...a little harsh to say the least. At least the Bills, Pats, and Jets all got a B+ or above.
Someone should have the guts to write an article and give every team an Incomplete. No offense to the people here that give draft grades but I consider it to be a completely useless exercise.
he's always vindictive when you don't do what he wants, there's no possibility that he is wrong, so we must be stupid
Do it yourself. The article links to the 2004-present draft grades. In case you're lazy, here's the link to the 2004 draft grades: http://www.footballoutsiders.com/nfl-draft/2004/you-say-tomato-i-say-future-pro-bowler