Would you trade Brandon Marshall for Michael Vick?

No. Miami needs a better play caller and QB but the answer isn't Vick.

 

Why would we have to trade Marshall to get Vick?

 

I would trade marshall for vick so fast.

 

Yes. Also, get rid of Henning because even with Vick, I'm sure old man river would still find a way to neutralize him.

 

So who the hell would Vick then throw to?

 

Well since you state it yourself that vick is a free agent at the end of the year, why would we need to trade Marshall. This is a rather useless debate. Bess, Hartline and Wallace/Moore just isnt going to get it done regardless of who's throwing the damn ball.

 

No. I wouldn't trade a used Kleenex for Ron Mexico.

 

No.
Getting a new QB won't change our coaching philosophies, our coaching staff proved that they are reluctant to change their ways because the are too damn stubborn. Not because i don't think Vick isn't a good player,'rather because he would not he put in position to succeed here. He is not your typicall drop-back passer,'we all know that; but I'm willing to het that exactly what they would try to make him in to, vs trying to utilize his unique skillset.

 

I don't know about the whole trading Marshall thing, but yes I would absolutely love Michael Vick in Miami.

 

Hell yeah

 

I don't want to see Vick in Miami. He is not going to be a long term solution.

 

This is the correct answer.

 

But you know, this actually sounds a lot better than a guy who'll just sit in the pocket forever (let alone makes horrid decisions vs any kind of zone coverage) and a guy who can't control his emotions (for better or for worse) and is a me-first receiver being paid $50 mil.

 

no unless he brings Reid, OC Mornhinweg, and QB coach with him

 

I'd be curious to see what Vick can do with this offensive line, Black Ninja, Moore, Hartline, and Lil Beast.

 

And if our DB's catch the other 5-6 balls that hit them in the hands we win by double digits and Henne maybe gets the ball more than one time without the endzone on his heels.

Henne played badly. But do you guys think it may just be possible that the weather and the Jests defense (who doesn't suck) maybe had a little to do with that play? Add on to it Henning being a ******ed old man and what we get is a recipe for disaster.

 

And no to the question. Vick will go back to sucking soon. It's hard NOT to succeed with the playmakers he has on that team.

 

keep Brandon acquire Vick, that would work

 

We do not have the players to maximize on Chad Henne's skillset, let alone Mike Vick. Hell, I wanted Vick when he came out of jail but I know we won't make him look good. Their offensive philosophy is built on speed and we certainly lack that.

 

You would have to be smoking crack not to take this trade, if it were available...Vick is playing better than ever, and he would attract a ton of free agents were he to play down here.

 

One of the dumbest ideas I have ever heard of.

Getting Vick would be a disaster as he won't look nearly as good in another system, especially ours run by a blistering idiot and a senile old man, but trading away the only playmaker on our offense to get him when he becomes a FA next year? Absolutely comical.

 

If you look at the receivers on the Eagles. You would see that they have no need for Marshall. So whether I would trade Vick for Marshall is irrelevant. Because the Eagles would never make that trade to begin with. I suspect that the Eagles will sign Vick to a long term contract and the Eagle QB on the block is going to be Kevin Kolb. So the question should be. Should the Dolphins trade their first round draft pick for Kolb?

 

first off, if he is a FA we dont need to trade for him and secondly eagles arent getting rid of him.

 

Henne played a poor game, but he didn't throw a pick. Thats some kind of improvement for me.

 

If that were to happen, I wouldn't watch a game or purchase any fins merchandise until Vick is off the team.

 

Bring back Ginn!!! Bring back Ginn!

 

Philly will franchise him, agreed.

 

NO.... I wouldn't trade Marshall for Vick.

You'd have Vick with no downfield threat to give him space to do anything with.
Vick is playing great b/c of the offense & system he's in (He has ALL the tools he needs to thrive!)

I couldn't imagine how bad Vick would look with only Bess, Fasano, Hartline, Moore, and Wallace to throw to and no ground game to help him out.

If he comes here, he says bye bye to his vertical threats that he loves so much. He says bye bye to having WRs and RB running free all around the field. He says bye bye to his better TE. He says bye bye to dumping it off to McCoy. He says bye bye to all his running room with no Jackson & Maclin stretching a defense thin up front.

Vick would NOT look like the Vick of Philly here.

 

Even though he'd be worse off here, it would be silly not to do such a trade. I'm surprised it's a topic of debate.

Anytime you can trade an under performing WR for a potential MVP QB, it is a coup.

 

Its so cute to see the Vick man-love that's going on.

Andy Reid's system made Doug Pederson, Mike McMahon and AJ Feely look good. He consistently puts a very good offense together regardless of player turnover. Andy is super aggressive and would have them throwing every down if he could.

 

Only the henne lovers will say no. All others will say yes in a second.

 

Anyway we could work in Desean Jackson to come with him?