I'm sick of this double standard. You want to give Cam credit for "making Ronnie Brown a probowl runner" and "Helping the rookies adjust to the NFL" But you want to blame other mediocre players for his losing streak. "No one could win with these players" Well if he can develop Ronnie Brown, how come he can't develop anyone else? Maybe Cam can't develop anyone. Maybe it IS just the players. But if that's the case, do you really want a coach that can't help his players play any better than they are?
I do agree with part of your thread. If you are going to get credit for what one player did, then you need to get some of the blame for what the other players are/are not doing. The only thing that I would add, is that a player of Ronnie Brown's talent level is definitely not the same as the talent level of a player such as Gado. Some players can only be developed to a certain level before they reach their peak, and it may not be as high as other players. Good point, though.
Either Cameron has been great with Brown or our previous coordinators haven't. Its really a judgment call, and I think it was Cameron. Tomlinson hasn't been the same since he left. But you also have to blame the poor conditioning that led to these injuries on him, to a degree. Same with the lack of good play calling.