I'm out on Tannehill

Playing Buff, NYJ, NE 6 times is MUCH tougher than playing Jax, Tenn, Houston 6 times. Still, Luck is superior to Tannehill in every category other than arm strength.

 

People talk about FH being a bad forum but the morons are drowning out the knowledgeable posters here too, and it's getting worse by the day.

 

You say this after you just insult people?

 

The qb debate has become ridiculous. Period. Not just rt but since Fiedler. As if qb succeeds or fails because a fan said so. We look at successes elsewhere and say see why can't we do that or take him. As if it doesn't matter the team/organ/system drafted into matters, that you could take luck put him on the phins and we would be in the champ game as we are composed now only change being luck. Or for the off the wall supprters that believe rt is no doubt a elite qb in waiting. Both leave out sign factors in judging. One is tannehill had little exp so he had to learn how to play the position as well as playing in the nfl. Our team as whole lacks, our coaches lack, our owner lacks. So while tannehill has not shown as much as we want can any of it be attributedto the ineptness of this organization?

I personally like tannehill and to me he has grown every year. Doesn't mean he will but considering where he started and who his head coach is I think he has it in him and can reach it. But I don't think he will fully with philboner in charge

 

I'm not talking about who agrees or who doesn't I'm talking about who's clueless and who isn't. There are a lot of people here who know very little about the game patting each other on the back bc there are throngs of equally clueless people here to agree with them.

No offense to you DJ but I don't need to have been here since 1973 to see that naïveté and ignorance rule the day.

 

Its funny how some posters come in here with their pistols and holsters telling me I shouldn't compare RT17 to AL12 but fail to tell the people who are detracting from AL12 to do the same... Agenda..

 

While we all argue about who's better/worse than Tannehill, the Seahawks defense has held opposing teams to 8 points a game through the last seven games. So, for as great as we hear Wilson is, he's not exactly being asked to go out and score a bunch of points.

 

Finheaven is awful.

 

LOL, so you are saying your posts are agendaless?

 

Im saying its funny how they tell me and few others not to compare RT17 to AL12 but the posters detracting from AL12, its no problem. Simple solution, you dont want me to make RT17 look like a fool with AL12 comparisons, then dont compare or detract from AL12 to support RT17. Simple.

 

Luck is the better QB, I haven't seen anyone claim otherwise. The debate is about whether he'd have 3 division titles in 3 years if he had to go thru Tom Brady to get them.

 

This thread is an unmitigated disaster but now I want to see it hit 100 pages!

 

He's playing in AFC Championship today against NE. Safe to say, his teams would be way more competitive to NE then RT17's team. And yes, many have detracted from AL12 in this thread recently.

 

He's 0-3 vs the Pats and has never come within 3 TDs of winning. Try again.

 

He's in AFC Championship game, remind me, has RT17 made the playoffs yet? Even an above .500 record?

 

Remind me again how wins/losses are purely a QB statistic?

This is why these threads are so useless.

 

What is "RT17" (which I think is totally juvenile) record vs. AL12? (also, juvenile).

Take your time.

 

Your backpedal is better than Cortland Finnegan's.

Luck gets a virtual free division title and home playoff game every year. Beating Denver last week was a great win and he's a terrific player but you totally miss the mark trying to make apples to apples comparisons between the Colts' and Dolphins' team successes.

 

Oh please, if the shoes were reversed you guys would be all over RT17's jock with same argument. And I would agree with you, but I dont live in fantasyland or fictitious places.

 

There are many marks missed by this guy.

 

Onice again providing nothing of substance to thread subject.

 

I respect the sentiment but as we talk more you'll see I'm not like the people you're trying to lump me in with.

 

Woooow Richard Sherman just made a tremendous play. A clear sign of how good Russell Wilson is lol.

 

Notice how the Seahawks DBs don't give 12-15 yards of space to the receivers at the line?

 

Tannehill haters would be losing their minds if Tannehill started a playoff game with that play.

 

Losing their minds out of joy that he finally made the playoffs, most likely.

 

I like the joke, but making the playoffs is about much more than simply the QB.

 

Tannehill shouldnt be compared to Luck. Luck is a Peyton Manning type of QB. Groomed to be a classic pocket passer. A better comparison for Tannehill is Aaron Rodgers. More of a gunslinger with mobility and both were projects when drafted.

 

Here's what will happen.

The pick Wilson threw will be deemed "not his fault" by the Tannehill haters, because it was tipped.

However, when Tannehill throws an INT that was tipped, it was a bad pass.

 

Three trips to the red zone and only 6 Pts allowed, look how good Wilson plays defense!

 

Because it's a thread about Tannehill?

 

Well, Tannehill's going to have a harder time living up to a Rodgers comparison than he is a Luck comparison. Luck may well develop to his full potential and still not be as good as Rodgers.

 

He's the topic of this thread.

 

Rodgers sat behind Favre for three years and took over a well oiled machine. That's very rare, as in Montana to Young rare.

 

your boy russell wilson is really crapping the bed so far. one int, one fumble, good thing he got that int in the end zone, such poor pocket presence taking that sack but he does play good red zone defense

 

Amazing how pedestrian Wilson looks when he's under quick pressure.