Anyone who argues that NFL staffs are somehow smarter than the average fan can heretofore go **** themselves. They may be more informed, but what they do with that information sometimes boggles the mind.
Given the right circumstances, be can be effective. Look no further than the Jets last playoff run. He played very well against Indy and NE on the road. And he wasn't bad against Pitt either. If he had a coach like Harbaugh, I bet he'd be much, much better. He received very little or poor coaching while on the Jets. For the right price, he's definitely worth a shot.